Exploring "New From Here" by Kelly Yang: Hopes and Disappointments
I was thrilled when I picked up "New from Here" by Kelly Yang, eager to dive into a story from an author I’ve adored in the past. Her “Front Desk” series has a special place on our family’s bookshelf, and I’ve found great value in the conversations sparked by books like “Parachutes.” So, when I learned about Yang’s latest release, I couldn’t wait to engage my nine-year-old son in listening to the audiobook, narrated by the talented Justin Chien. What I didn’t expect was to feel so conflicted about my experience.
Themes and Characters
At its core, "New from Here" tackles timely topics like anti-Asian bigotry, particularly in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. The anti-racist message resonated strongly, providing a launching point for some crucial discussions with my son about how to stand against intolerance. We found ourselves pausing frequently to dissect themes, which is always a plus in any book.
Another aspect I appreciated was Yang’s portrayal of family dynamics, particularly the mother’s struggle to balance work and parenting. As a mom, I felt seen in the depiction of a working mother who was neither the "SuperMom" stereotype nor a villain. This realistic representation of a busy, overwhelmed mom was refreshing, and the father’s supportive role was a positive note. However, I found myself grappling with the portrayal of ADHD in the central character, Knox. While I commend Yang for including a character with ADHD, the exaggerated depiction felt problematic and, dare I say, at times almost harmful.
Narrative Style and Pacing
The pacing of the story didn’t sit well with either of us. We frequently exchanged exclamations in disbelief as Knox and his siblings engaged in increasingly absurd antics. For instance, the plot twist involving a garage sale of priceless family heirlooms felt more like a caricature than authentic childhood behavior. My son was particularly dismayed, exclaiming that such actions could lead others to perceive kids with ADHD as simply “stupid.” It was frustrating to witness a character, meant to represent a neurodiverse experience, spiraling into over-the-top impulsivity that lacked depth or realism.
Memorable Moments and Takeaways
Despite these critiques, there were a few moments that made us laugh aloud. However, they were overshadowed by a sense of incredulity as we questioned the logic of some plotlines and character arc resolutions. I appreciated how we talked through our disbelief, but I wished those conversations had been inspired by more relatable actions of the characters, rather than fantastical ones.
Conclusion: Who Might Enjoy This Book?
In summary, "New from Here" sparks important conversations and features heartfelt moments that will resonate with some readers. While I encourage others to dive in—especially those who love Yang’s previous work—I also urge readers to approach with caution regarding its depiction of ADHD. The quality of the audiobook helps shore up some of the experience, allowing for an enjoyable listening journey.
Although this installment didn’t hit the mark for us, I will certainly look forward to Yang’s next middle-grade offering, hopeful that it will encapsulate a more nuanced representation of the challenges and joys of childhood. If you’re looking for a book that champions anti-racism and tackles separation within families, it’s worth a read, just perhaps with reservations about its portrayal of ADHD. Happy reading!