Book Review: Murder at an Irish Castle by Ellery Adams
Ah, the allure of an Irish castle! When I stumbled upon Murder at an Irish Castle, I was instantly intrigued by the title and the promise of mystery amid sparkling landscapes and charming folklore. As a lover of cozy mysteries (and perhaps a little escapism), this book felt like it could whisk me away on a grand adventure. I offer my heartfelt thanks to Ellie Brannigan, Dreamscape Media, and Netgalley for granting me a complimentary audiobook version—my opinions are, of course, my own.
Set against the backdrop of Ireland’s breathtaking countryside, the story follows our main character, who must rebuild her life after the devastating loss of everything she holds dear. The weight of her circumstances is palpable; I marveled at her resilience, as I likely would have curled up in a ball, gorked on tranquilizers. Yet, idyllic settings can be deceiving. While there is indeed a murder lurking in the plot, the narrative felt more like women’s fiction than a traditional whodunit. Instead of high-stakes sleuthing, we witness our protagonist navigating her complicated new life, encountering the colorful quirks of her housemates (or should I say “estatemates”?) along the way.
Let’s chat about pacing. The plot meanders at a leisurely stroll—think of our main character going on “dates,” shopping for fabric, or setting up her workspace—instead of the brisk, gripping pace I’d anticipated. There was a hint of mystery enveloping the castle, but it was often overshadowed by narratives that felt more like filler than plot. For a story labeled a mystery, I longed for more tension, and at times found myself skipping ahead, on the lookout for the juicy bits.
As I reflect on the characters, I must admit they evoked a diverse array of feelings. The main character was undeniably likable and sympathetic, but I couldn’t fully relate to her lavish lifestyle. Equally frustrating was Keira, a secondary character whose whiny, entitled demeanor drove me to distraction. Ironically, the character I adored most was a sweet dog that clumsily played the role of witness. Ah, fiction can sometimes throw in the unexpected!
Then there’s the narrative technique to address. Traci Odom skillfully captures accents, particularly the smooth tones of Irish men, but I found her portrayal of the Irish female characters jarring—Keira’s piercing voice made my skin crawl. Rather unfortunate, given that Keira is central to the story’s conflict.
The book’s final act tried to tie the loose ends with some intriguing twists, yet one aspect baffled me: the logic behind the uncle’s death and the cutting of hydraulic lines on the tractor. I couldn’t fathom why a villain would tamper with machinery in such a convoluted manner, leading to confusion rather than clarity in what was supposed to be a shocking reveal.
In conclusion, if Murder at an Irish Castle is a cozy, it’s one that strays from the genre’s conventions. For readers seeking a thrilling mystery, this likely won’t satisfy; however, those interested in character-driven narratives and diverse personal journeys may find their hearts touched. Personally, while the book didn’t resonate with me as deeply as I’d hoped, it nudged me to consider perspectives outside my own experiences. Whether you’re in it for the light romance, a cozy read, or simply the beauty of the Irish countryside, this one’s worth a peek—but don’t expect to be on the edge of your seat.
Discover more about Murder at an Irish Castle (Irish Castle Mystery #1) on GoodReads >>