House of Blight: A Mixed Bag of Promises
When I first stumbled upon House of Blight by D.M. Mayfield, I was genuinely intrigued. The gothic romantasy genre has a special place in my heart, and the promise of magic, intrigue, and a sprawling estate sprinkled with dark secrets called to me like a siren’s song. That beautiful cover art and evocative summary had me all a-buzz, but by the 40% mark, I found myself struggling to maintain that spark of excitement. Here’s why this journey led me to a reluctant "Did Not Finish."
The Premise That Hooked Me
House of Blight introduces us to Edira Brillwyn, a threadmender with rare healing powers intricately laced with the weight of sacrifice. A compelling start indeed! The conflict really kicks off when her brothers contract a terrifying blight, and Edira is thrust into a world of the powerful Fernglove family. Here, we encounter the charming yet morally ambiguous Orin, the head of the family. The idea of a love triangle, particularly one that pivots around familial bonds and magical quirks, had me curious. However, as the chapters unfolded, that intrigue started to dissipate.
Characters and Themes That Fell Flat
While the premise promised depth, the characters, unfortunately, felt flat. Edira’s internal struggles and her budding attraction to Orin didn’t resonate as strongly as I had hoped. I understand that building characters can be a slow burn, but I couldn’t connect with Edira—or any of the characters, honestly. When I found myself bored and indifferent, it became harder to push past the awkward moments and cluttered world-building. The magical system, with its confusing "Evers," also left me feeling somewhat lost, rather than enchanted.
And then there’s the gothic allure that was conspicuously absent. I was expecting rich, atmospheric descriptions to envelop me as I turned each page, but the setting didn’t convey the haunting charm or thrill I anticipated. I kept seeing comparisons to One Dark Window floating around, and I must admit, House of Blight fell starkly short of that mark.
A Missed Connection
One quote that stood out was, “The only pain I’d ever intentionally inflict on you is the agony of making you wait to feel the pleasure of release.” This line held a flicker of promise, but sadly, the story’s pacing never delivered that promised pleasure. The narrative felt sluggish overall—pointless filler overshadowing poignant moments that could have thrived under a tighter structure. I found myself scrolling through TikTok instead of being lost in Edira’s world, a sign that my connection was all but severed.
Bottom Line
So here we are—after a generous 40% read, I had to make the tough decision to DNF House of Blight. With its overwhelming dullness and uninspired writing, I couldn’t justify the price tag that comes with it. I would recommend this book to readers who enjoy slow-building romances and are less troubled by characters lacking depth. If you thrive on gothic themes and traditional magic systems, you might find something different that captures your heart better.
While I wish I could have loved House of Blight, I’ve learned that not every book can resonate. And that’s perfectly okay. Until next time, happy reading!
Discover more about House of Blight (The Threadmender Chronicles, #1) on GoodReads >>