Hip-Hop Is History: A Reflective Journey Through Rhythm and Rhyme
From one Aquarius to another, I found myself thoroughly intrigued by Questlove’s latest endeavor, Hip-Hop Is History. As a lifelong hip hop head born in 1986, this audiobook was a compelling addition to my reading list, promising a deep exploration of a genre that’s shaped cultural landscapes. However, my journey through this auditory experience was a bit of an emotional rollercoaster.
To be candid, the initial chapters felt somewhat arduous. I often turned to this audiobook between other reads, grappling with the fact that Questlove, while a prominent figure in mainstream hip hop culture, didn’t quite resonate as my go-to hip hop aficionado. His presence on late-night television—as a recognizable staple—can be comforting, but for someone like me who thrives on the historical roots and nuances of hip hop, that alone doesn’t qualify him as an expert.
As I pushed past the slower parts, I began to engage more deeply with the material. The warmth in Questlove’s voice and the humor he injected made the learning curve enjoyable. Still, my excitement took a nosedive when he started to critique Kanye West. Now, I hold Kanye’s contributions in high regard—after all, the man is responsible for The College Dropout and has crafted some of the most emotive pieces in hip hop history. To hear Questlove downplay Kanye’s artistic genius felt like a serious misstep. His comparisons to Drake were baffling, and I found myself shouting, “O V Ho!” in my car—how can we equate Drake’s manufactured pop star aura with the complexity of Kanye West?
Despite appreciating Questlove’s passion, his dismissive tone toward Kanye seemed driven by personal biases rather than artistic evaluation. The notion that Kanye’s eccentricities could overshadow his monumental contributions is something I simply cannot accept. Context is key; Quest talks about listening to Yeezus in secret, while his handling of modern Jay-Z feels oddly timid. Does he revere the business mogul more than the original artist who inspired us?
What kept me listening, however, was the book’s thought-provoking nature. Questlove provoked reflections on various artists and albums, making me revisit corners of hip hop I thought I’d fully explored. Humorous anecdotes intertwined with passionate critiques often made me chuckle or nod our heads in agreement. Still, I had to dock some points for his tone—dismissive and, at times, pompous—with an intro that felt more rambling than resonant.
In my overall assessment, Hip-Hop Is History is a mixtape of thoughts that spark necessary debates among hip hop lovers. If you’re a fan like me—someone who relishes in the lyrical architecture of the genre and its cultural implications—you may find both enjoyment and frustration while navigating its pages. Questlove’s journey through hip hop is rich, but it’s marred by some missteps that might not sit well with die-hard fans.
As for whether I’d listen to Questlove’s other books? Probably. Despite the critiques, his voice is important in contemporary discourse. So, if you’re open to engaging with the complexities of hip hop, Hip-Hop Is History could be a worthwhile read, even if it pushes you to think critically about what you cherish in the genre.
Discover more about Hip-Hop Is History on GoodReads >>