Book Review: Never Enough: When Achievement Culture Becomes Toxic—and What We Can Do About It by Judith L. Herman
There’s something undeniably captivating about Judith L. Herman’s title, Never Enough: When Achievement Culture Becomes Toxic—and What We Can Do About It. It hung in the air like a challenge, prompting me to dive deeper into the concept of achievement culture that permeates our lives. As someone who often feels the weight of societal expectations, I was drawn in, hoping to uncover insights about our relentless pursuit of validation and success.
Right off the bat, Herman sets the stage for a discussion that feels both urgent and eerily familiar. The central theme revolves around the societal pressures that push parents—especially mothers—into an endless cycle of achievement, projecting their aspirations onto their children. While I appreciate the author’s well-intended exploration, I couldn’t help but feel that the narrative sometimes faltered under the weight of unexamined claims and shaky scientific references. It’s a topic that calls for nuance, yet the execution often felt more like a hopeful plea than a fully fleshed-out argument.
Herman expertly highlights the absurdity of achievement culture, illustrating how it often masquerades as harmless ambition. I found myself chuckling at her anecdotes—like the fish tacos in Phoenix, which, let’s be honest, should have raised a red flag about culinary choices. Such moments humanize the text, anchoring it with a conversational tone that makes it relatable. Yet, there’s a deeper essence shining through; the book underscores a stark reality: our children cannot merely be extensions of ourselves, trapped in the narrow crusade of elite status.
The writing style, while accessible, sometimes left me craving more depth. The narrative sometimes felt disjointed, with anecdotes strung together rather than fully melded into a cohesive argument. Take, for instance, Herman’s point about resilience—she argues that helping caregivers can ultimately benefit children. While I absolutely agree that overworked parents often lose sight of their own well-being, I felt a tinge of discomfort as the narrative shifted towards self-care as a panacea for parenting pressures. It left me pondering whether this guidance served as a genuine call for balance or another form of elitist self-indulgence.
One moment that truly resonated with me was Herman’s contemplation about the skewed metrics of success: “…causing kids to have to break their necks to distinguish themselves within a very narrow band of excellence.” This struck a chord, especially in a world where social networks amplify the pressure to outshine peers. For many of us, moving through insular communities stacked with high achievers can be isolating, and this acknowledgment brought solace.
Despite its shortcomings, Never Enough offers a valuable perspective worth considering. The book seems tailored for parents caught in the whirlwind of societal expectations, particularly mothers who often carry the brunt of this pressure. It’s a reminder that we must not let ambition overshadow the joys of childhood or the simple act of nourishing our little ones’ spirits.
In the end, if you’re a parent battling the incessant chatter of achievement culture, or simply someone curious about the dynamics shaping modern parenting, this book might spark some necessary conversations. While I left with more questions than answers, the experience of wrestling with these ideas was impactful. Never Enough ultimately encourages reflection—a crucial step in carving out a healthier future for our children amidst the relentless chase for success.
If you enjoy this review, I invite you to read it again on my website and support independent internet!
Discover more about Never Enough: When Achievement Culture Becomes Toxic-an… on GoodReads >>